The Free Press, Mankato, MN

State, national news

August 8, 2012

Father struggles with death of son from rare amoeba in lake

MANKATO — The father of a boy who died of a suspected rare amoeba infection says he's struggling with the shock of his son's sudden death.

Jim Ariola, of Wyoming, Minn., told the St. Paul Pioneer Press for a story published Wednesday (http://bit.ly/PF8vrn ) that his 9-year-old son swam in Lily Lake in Stillwater last week. Health officials said that that's where the child likely contracted rare form of meningitis that caused his death Tuesday. The amoeba enters the body through the nose during swimming or diving and travels up a nerve to the brain.

Minnesota's only previously confirmed case was in August 2010. That child also swam in Lily Lake, which is now closed to swimming until further notice.

Ariola identified his son to the Star Tribune of Minneapolis (http://bit.ly/QMLw4P ) as Jack Ariola Erenberg. He said Jack was going to be in fourth grade this year in Stillwater, where he lived with his mother.

"It was just a fluke," Ariola told the Pioneer Press. "You can't keep kids off a beach; what the hell are you supposed to do? He loved going swimming. He was a great brother, great son," he said.

Jack had a brother and three sisters.

"He had a lot of plans coming up. Hockey was supposed to start (Wednesday) night," Ariola said.

Assistant state epidemiologist Rich Danila said he was "99 percent sure" that the boy died of primary amoebic meningoencephalitis, a parasitic infection so rare that there have been only 125 cases in the United States since 1924. It involves an amoeba called Naegleria fowleri that's found in warm freshwater. He said samples were being sent to U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention in Atlanta for testing Wednesday to confirm the diagnosis.

While it's not certain that Jack or the 7-year-old victim in the previous case acquired the infections from Lily Lake, Danlia said, local authorities acting on the health department's recommendation closed it to swimming Tuesday "out of an abundance of caution. ... It's the most likely source."

Jack was traveling with his mother in Grand Marais when he fell ill Friday and rapidly deteriorated, Ariola said. He said his son became incoherent and was hallucinating, and that he was sick to his stomach and had bad headaches.

"He didn't know who was around him," Ariola said.

The boy was flown to a Duluth hospital, where a specialist contacted the CDC and the Mayo Clinic.

"They looked under the scope, and that's what they decided it was — Naegleria fowleri," Ariola said.

Ariola said his son's condition worsened Saturday.

"He didn't wake back up. They put him on a ventilator, had a machine monitoring his brain. ... His brain just started shutting down," Ariola said.

Jack was taken off life support Tuesday.

The infection is almost always fatal, Danila said. Symptoms start with headaches and move to confusion, inability to communicate, blurred vision and finally coma and death.

"It's associated with diving. The best way to decrease the risks is to wear nose clips, don't dive or hold the nose," Danila said.

All the other recorded U.S. cases have occurred south of Minnesota, with the closest case having happened in Missouri, Danila said. That's because the amoebas typically proliferate in warmer waters, though they are found in Minnesota and can go dormant and survive winter months, he said.

Danila said lakes can't be treated to kill the amoeba. He said reopening Lily Lake would likely depend on cooler temperatures, when the amoebas go dormant.

As for next year, Danila said, "we'll have to think about it. ... We'll at least put up signs to let people know the risks."

The fact that this summer has been particularly warm might have allowed the amoeba to thrive, Danila said.

"We do worry about this because we know that temperatures are increasing and we know that water temperatures are increasing," Danila said. "There's a risk but it's a very small risk, the risk would be greater for smaller, shallower areas where the water can get very hot and amoeba can proliferate."

Text Only | Photo Reprints
State, national news
  • Severe Weather-9 Photo gallery: Oklahoma tornadoes Photographs of the damage from tornadoes that hit areas around Oklahoma City on Monday, May 21

    May 21, 2013 18 Photos

  • Severe Weather Oklahoma tornadoes death toll at 24

    MOORE, Okla. (AP) — Search-and-rescue crews worked through the night after a monstrous tornado barreled through the Oklahoma City suburbs, demolishing an elementary school and reducing homes to piles of splintered wood.

    May 21, 2013 4 Photos

  • Toddler stabbed in Rochester last year has died

    The young boy critically injured in a stabbing attack in Rochester last year has died at a hospital in Nebraska.

    May 21, 2013

  • AP Phone Records Legal Landscape Policy, discretion guide media sources probes WASHINGTON (AP) — It was a rare moment in relations between the media and the government: In 2008, FBI Director Robert Mueller called the top editors at The New York Times and The Washington Post to apologize because the bureau had improperly obtaine

    May 21, 2013 1 Photo

  • House passes bill on lying about military medals WASHINGTON (AP) — People who falsely claim they have received a military medal in order to obtain money or government benefits could face up to a year in jail under legislation that easily passed the House Monday. The Stolen Valor Act, sponsored by

    May 21, 2013

  • Planting conditions much improved in Minnesota ST. PAUL, Minn. (AP) — A miserable start to spring planting for Minnesota farmers has greatly improved with a stretch of better weather. The U.S. Department of Agriculture says farmers have planted more than half of the 9 million acres of corn expec

    May 21, 2013

  • Minn. lawmakers wrap up historic session

    Minnesota lawmakers worked right up to the end Monday before adjourning a session that produced $2 billion in tax hikes and a historic vote on gay marriage.

    May 21, 2013

  • Severe Weather-6 Massive tornado roars through Oklahoma City suburb; at least 20 children among dead

    A monstrous tornado as much as a mile wide roared through the Oklahoma City suburbs Monday, flattening entire neighborhoods with winds up to 200 mph, setting buildings on fire and landing a direct blow on an elementary school. There w

    May 20, 2013 5 Photos

  • Session's last day arrives for Minnesota lawmakers

    ST. PAUL, Minn. (AP) — Short on sleep and time, state lawmakers darted Monday toward the finish of a legislative session that already has produced a hefty tax increase, substantial new money for schools and a landmark law legalizing gay marriage.

    May 20, 2013

  • Minn. House defeats construction projects bill

    ST. PAUL, Minn. (AP) — The Minnesota House has turned back an $800 million construction projects bill that failed to win a needed super-majority.

    May 20, 2013